Chương 33: All the Same
One moment — Royal Road is checking your connection · Waffle Unleashed · 46 chương · ~31 phút đọc · Tạo 24/09/2026
I earned some points for Ravenclaw by helping out with Halloween preparations. Not that I was very useful next to the teachers, Hagrid, or even the prefects, but earning acknowledgements for the effort by those in charge was a pleasant side-effect of staying safe. The party itself was… a party. I never liked all the noise or pressure of a large crowd of people. Unlike normal lunches and dinners, I felt obligated to attend. Not just for my safety, but for my betting pool and the nature of celebrations in general.
At least the food was a step beyond normal fare from the house-elves. Apparently, for important occasions, the elves worked themselves far harder than was typical. Not every meal at Hogwarts was an extravagant feast. It was usually a lot more tame, and a lot less resource-intensive. Normal food was still delivered magically from the kitchens below on ordinary days, but it didn't have the same variety or polish as a feast. The decorations weren't bad either.
A lot better than the cheap paper cutouts and plastic toys so common in the states. Magic really did wonders for ambiance. The long tables were removed and replaced with numerous round ones. Hagrid's pumpkins were large enough that they had been hollowed out and magically reinforced, allowing for small groups of students to take their meals inside one for much appreciated, semi-private eating. The main attraction among the students had been a band of skeletons, enchanted to provide live music.
They weren't my favorite. It was just extra noise to me, contributing to a steadily worsening headache as the night wore on. Dumbledore had conjured them, and he apparently liked the oldies. The real oldies, as in music with no vocals. I hesitated to call the genre 'Classical' because I couldn't recognize any of the songs. I think many of the students were a little disappointed in them too, from the snippets of conversation I heard discussing it.
Too much hype for something appealing more towards people as old as the students' grandparents instead of themselves. I gave myself an hour to settle in, eat, and experience my first wizard holiday before I got to work. There was money to be made, and bets that needed finalizing. Some people—like Mathis—had waited until the last moment to put in their predictions. Others made the decision on the spot to join in; the festive atmosphere and start of the quidditch season lowering inhibitions.
In Mathis's case, he specifically asked to view mine. Then he copied everything I had written down. When I glared at him, he had the nerve to just shrug and point out that I had never lost a bet. So he wasn't really betting on the pool, but rather on me. The jerk. This meant I would be winning fractionally less with every game. Bets ended up split in four predictable ways. Even then, there were a few brave souls that tried to play the odds rather than just side with their house.
Ravenclaw had won the cup last year, absolutely dominating Gryffindor in the final match as Harry was in the Hospital Wing due to the fight over the Philosopher's Stone. However, two of our seven players—our Captain and our Seeker—had graduated. As such, we were facing much lower expectations this year. Whoever ended up winning—even if my view of the future proved incredibly wrong—I was making bank. Known and popular betting games were highly successful when introduced to sports fans of a different culture.
Who would have guessed? I used some of my profits from the commissioning fees to accept a few items as an alternative form of payment, concluding they could always be re-sold to others at a later date. However, unlike with Ginny, I demanded those who were interested to pay upfront. It was a surprisingly popular option. Most of the offered items were of questionable use and value, and I ended up needing to bug some of the prefects and teachers to verify their worth.
One Ravenclaw fifth-year student paid with a set of cheap recording stones that his mother had sent him for recording lectures. They functioned like a normal muggle tape player, playing back sounds they heard in the voices of the lecturer. Unfortunately, sometimes the stones would get confused and start rambling about an unrelated topic, or make up information entirely when their memory failed; all still said in the voice of the lecturer. As such, their stated use was very questionable.
I jumped on them mainly for the possibility of recording Richard's crow. I didn't know if a magical recording would have the same effect as the real thing, but I couldn't exactly carry a kidnapped rooster around the corridors all day. Despite myself—and my awareness that Ginny had slipped out of the Great Hall near the beginning of the night to 'use the toilets' then never returned—I had fun. As the party ended, Dumbledore rose to address the respectfully quiet hall.
"Good evening, everyone.
"These next few months will see the air grow crisp and the days grow shorter. We will welcome Winter and her season of quiet beauty, frosted mornings, and snow-covered wonder. It is a time when the world slows down, inviting us to reflect, to gather, and, most importantly, to connect.
"Though the chill may settle outside, let us remember that warmth is never far. It lives in our smiles, our laughter, and the company we keep. In this season of cold, friendship is the fire that keeps us warm.
"So let's embrace the season not just with coats and scarves, but with open hearts. Let's reach out, check in, and remind one another that no one walks through these cold halls alone.
"Here's to a season of peace, togetherness, and the warmth that only true friendship can bring.
"Thank you." The students and staff gave polite claps and a few scattered cheers. Fred and George going all in on hollering and whistling in approval. Then the students began to rise and file en-masse out of the Great Hall with the teachers hanging back. The Hufflepuffs broke off first, heading across the Entrance Hall and down the staircase that led past the kitchens. The other three houses took the marble staircase up. My anxiety spiked as we neared Moaning Myrtle's bathroom.
I had intentionally positioned myself at the front of the student body to get a good view. I turned the shadowed corner. Skinny, dark-haired, pale, and stoic. Harry was standing in the center of the gloomy corridor before an apparently dead Mrs Norris, lit by low-burning torches on the wall. A message—written in what looked like blood—on the wall. A pool of eerie mirror-like water across the floor. Ron and Hermione were there as well, separate from the crowd, but cowering away from the scene.
Less noticeable for not standing in the reflective waters. It was quite the image. This story has been unlawfully obtained without the author's consent. Report any appearances on Amazon."' Enemies of the heir, beware'? You'll be next mudbloods," came a cold jeering voice. In the crowded darkness, it could almost be assumed Harry had said it. A short second-year like Malfoy certainly didn't stand out much in the crowd.
"What's going on here?! What's going on?" Filch snarled as he pushed his way to the front of the crowd. I took the opportunity to back away. I'd seen enough. This was important, but nothing next to what was coming. Moreover, if the next scene appeared where it was supposed to, then I could conclude that everything occurring right now ended up the same as canon. I didn't move particularly fast though. People were pressing in and I wasn't large enough to force my way through, particularly without drawing attention.
"My cat! My cat! What's happened to Mrs Norris." The despair in his voice made my gut plummet a bit. I was on the fence about Filch. He was incredibly unpleasant to be around and took his aggression out on the students, but… he did care about Mrs Norris. That counted for something in my book.
"You! You. You've murdered my cat. You killed her. I'll kill you. I'll–""Argus," Dumbledore said, drawing all attention to him in an instant. A few other teachers were right behind him, gently pushing their way through the crowd. The shifting allowed me to navigate away with much more ease. Most students were trying to get closer and all too happy to have someone getting out of their way in the shuffle. Once freed, I took the stairs up towards the DADA classroom and all but ran the short distance to the door.
The classroom was unlocked, and so was Lockhart's office. My eye twitched. I wanted to comment on the lack of security, but now wasn't the time. Instead I took note that if I ever got a less than ideal result from a homework assignment I could take it into my own hands to correct the man's clear inability to grade properly. On the other hand, would anyone care about perfect marks in his class? A lock was pointless if there was nothing worth protecting behind it.
I largely ignored the dozens of moving photos of the man—in various states of self-care routines as they panicked and rushed to make themselves presentable—and moved over to a massive wardrobe in the corner. I opened it, and stepped into Narnia. Not really, but the clothing warehouse inside was just shy of being large enough to develop its own weather patterns. I left the door slightly ajar and it gave me a fairly decent view of the room.
Not long after I settled in, the door opened again and expected people came in. Lockhart, McGonagall, Dumbledore carrying Mrs Norris, the trio, Snape, and Filch bringing up the rear. McGonagall lit the candles with a flick of her wand and Dumbledore set Mrs Norris on the main desk.
After taking out the Elder Wand, he began to examine her in earnest, but mostly through what appeared to be a physical examination; pokes and prods with his fingers, getting in close with his face and looking at her fur from an inch away. It was interesting. I would've thought he'd use the wand more. Did it function as an amplifier even from just being held? The trio took seats at the edge of the room, looking very nervous.
McGonagall shadowed Dumbledore, either attempting to ape his methods or doing a similar examination. Snape loomed. His back was to me, so he was probably focused more on the trio themselves. Filch was sobbing in a chair near the desk. Every wracking gasp of air felt like a very thin knife stabbing into my chest. Then there was Lockhart. Making a complete fool of himself as he annoyingly went on and on. Jumping to conclusions and clearly making Filch more agitated.
I'd be more upset at him, but this wasn't his usual boasting; he was scared and trying to cover it up by projecting false confidence. Dumbledore eventually progressed to using the wand, and not long after stood to pronounce, "She's not dead, Argus."
"Not dead? But why's she all stiff and frozen?" he replied, hope back in his voice.
"She has been petrified–""Ahh! I thought so," Lockhart declared.
"–But how? I cannot say."
'I cannot say' instead of 'I do not know'? A distinct word choice there, Dumbledore. Was I reading too deep into a passing comment?
"Ask him!" Filch roared, and turned on Harry.
"No second-year could have done this," replied Dumbledore calmly.
"It would take Dark Magic of the most advanced–""He did it! He did it! You saw what he wrote on the wall. He found—in my office—He knows I'm a– I'm a– He knows I'm a… squib."
"I never touched Mrs Norris!" Harry said with a mix of anger and fear.
"And I don't even know what a squib is."
"Rubbish! He saw my Quick-Spell letter."
"If I might speak, Headmaster?" Snape spoke for the first time since entering the office.
"Potter and his friends may have simply been in the wrong place at the wrong time, but we do have a set of suspicious circumstances here. Why was he in the upstairs corridor at all? Why wasn't he at the Hallowe'en Feast?" The trio began talking over themselves explaining about the Deathday party. Largely giving me another headache as I tried to parse the three loud voices vying for attention.
"But why not join the Feast afterwards? Why go up to that corridor?"
"Because– Because– we were tired and wanted to go to bed?" The delivery was so weak I doubted even Lockhart believed him.
"Without any supper? I didn't think ghosts provided food fit for living people at their parties," Snape said in triumph.
"We weren't hungry," Ron said, right as his stomach began to protest loudly. I blinked at the coincidence. That had to have been magic, but whose?
"I suggest, Headmaster, that Potter is not being entirely truthful. It might be a good idea for him to be deprived of certain privileges until he decides to tell us the whole story. I personally feel he should be taken off the Gryffindor quidditch team until he is ready to be honest."
"Really Severus?" McGonagall replied sharply.
"I see no reason to stop the boy from playing quidditch. This cat wasn't hit over the head with a broomstick. There is no evidence at all that Potter has done anything wrong." I wanted to roll my eyes at where this conversation had just ended up. Sports? Really? There was an attack and all the two Heads of Houses were concerned about was taking the star athlete off the team for a yearly contest that doesn't matter.
"Innocent until proven guilty, Severus," Dumbledore said firmly.
"My cat has been petrified!" Filch screeched.
"I want to see some punishment!"
"We will be able to cure her, Argus. Professor Sprout has recently managed to procure some mandrakes. As soon as they've reached their full size, I will have a potion made that will revive Mrs Norris."
"I'll do it!" Lockhart said.
"I must have done it a hundred times. I could whip up a mandrake restorative draught in my sleep."
"Excuse me, but I believe I am the Potions Master at this school." Snape glared at Lockhart with extreme venom and derision, causing the other man to wilt slightly.
"You may go," Dumbledore stated to the trio. They left. All but fleeing from the teachers as if they were about to pounce and attack.
"Dumbledore, you can't honestly let that slide. Potter was lying through his teeth about what led him to the site of the attack.""' What led him to the site'. Your own words betray your thoughts on the matter, Severus. Harry was not responsible for the attack, and I'm sure if he thought what he experienced was important he will speak up about it before long. Particularly if given a less… accusatory environment to express himself in. Now, would you be so kind as to fetch Pomona?
She should be made aware of the need the mandrakes will now need to serve."
'I'll go! I may be able to provide her some tips on how to ensure the health of such tricky little plants.'
"You may join Severus. Thank you. Minerva, if you would take Argus and Mrs Norris to the Hospital Wing? I believe she deserves a good bed to rest in while for the several months it will take to grow the mandrakes to maturity."
"Of course, Headmaster."
"Thank you," Dumbledore said with a nod. The groups left, leaving only Dumbledore in the office. He stared for a time, apparently lost in thought, before turning to leave himself. At the door he paused. Looking out into the classroom.
"One can learn a great deal by observing quietly…" He paused, but not long enough to be expecting an answer.
"Though I do hope you do not become too fond of hiding, for life has a way of calling us forward when we least expect it. Have a good night, and please, hurry to bed. Things are not always as safe as I would wish them to be." He walked out, leaving the door to the office open and the candles lit. I debated trying to out-wait a potentially invisible Dumbledore ready to get a look at which student was hiding in Lockhart's office, but quickly gave up on the idea.
Dumbledore could reasonably wait for hours for me to emerge, and if I didn't—as in, slept here then waited till morning to emerge—the results of breaking curfew would be bound to expose me regardless. If I wasn't in the common room after an attack, one of my roommates would be bound to kick up a panic. A good thing to remember for later. If I wanted to stay out all night, I'd need someone in the tower to be aware and ready to cover if someone else realizes I'm gone.
I left my hiding spot and quickly began making my way back to Ravenclaw Tower, thinking over all the details of what I witnessed. Dumbledore wasn't anywhere to be seen in the classroom. As far as I could tell, the story was the exact same. Near enough word-for-word. It was eerie. Almost eldritch. People acting out a script I knew from another life. I, or rather Lyra, wasn't a named character in those books.
I'd confirmed this over and over in the last couple of months, but my presence hadn't noticeably changed this night. Admittedly, I hadn't done much, but I hadn't done nothing, either. My existence alone should be impactful enough to change a word or two, shouldn't it? This whole event was too close to the books to be chance. Was this proof of my theories about Fate? Evidence that trying to influence the main plot would result in backlash? Was I imagining an issue where none existed?
Was I just making up a reason not to speak out and lose my advantages? I had the perfect time right there at the end to talk to Dumbledore alone, but I didn't. I needed to push harder. To confirm how 'set' the book's events were. Once I knew it was safe, I could begin to change things in earnest.

Giữ khẩu khí thanh khiết — không văn tục, không phá chính trị.
Nhập môn