Chương 134: Chapter 2.70: Crimes and Punishments

One moment — Royal Road is checking your connection · TheDyingOfLight · 140 chương · ~20 phút đọc · Tạo 10/10/2026

The initial study of the legal documents had been as dry and informative as Favius had anticipated. He stretched and took a sip of honeyed pine-mint tea as he reflected on the afternoon's work. Marcus wasn't wrong. The marital law really does favor the head of the family, and we can freeze her out quite easily beyond the moderate stipend he is required to pay her, like any other member of the familia. His eyes flicked over to one of the documents, to one set of letters of jurisprudence.

And there is ample precedent for treating problematic marital partners that way. He smiled bitterly. They basically have no legal standing when it comes to clan or familia affairs. The letters had taken up most of his reading. After a few questions, he had been directed to a woman whose doe eyes and ears had made her deer shifter ancestry very obvious. She was Serran's and thus the familia's main legal advisor. He stared at the third of the letters he had read so far.

Next he smiled at one of the lists of dates and names which indicated to whom the woman would send the documents after she was done studying them. Interesting that jurists in Cindrath have something like semi-professional journals.

Taking another gulp of tea and enjoying the low sun shine into the library, he stared down at the text he was currently reading, a rather poignant analysis illuminating what appeared to be a hot subject among some Cindrathi jurists: proposed reforms regarding filial collective punishment. I got used to them thinking about things in ritual and traditional terms. Feels strange that they have diverse opinions on this.

His eyes flicked over the sections of the Traditionalists, who argued that familial privilege inherently created an expectation of familial punishment. But the apparently dominant position in the discourse criticized collective responsibility based on the idea that justice ought to concern itself with acts. Thus, unless the entire group had committed the criminal act, extermination based on kinship lacked a virtuous grounding.

A knock on the door interrupted his musings, and Brutus and Phaidros both entered the room. A servant followed soon after with a platter of snacks.

"So, little cousin," smiled the Minurian.

"I heard you retreated here to study the law. Tell me, what have you concluded?" Favius grinned at his uncle and ordered his thoughts.

"Is this a test?"

"Everything is a test of your skill, so you best make sure that you give me a winning answer." He replied while Brutus shared out some heady wine. Favius nodded and poked the scroll with the Penal Code.

"While fines and enslavement are mostly standardized across the Republic, many major cities retained traditional punishments. Stonings in the case of Rhexion, drownings in Lirene, and for us Cindrathi, beatings at the stake." He paused and snatched a piece of spiced and roasted mutton while reflecting on the word. The Irilian term is closer to pillaring, but that just sounds weird if I think about it like that.

"And how do you civilized Irilians differentiate the kind of beatings that are handed out in public?" It's still kind of ridiculous to me that they are just color-coding it. It makes it pretty intuitive, though.

"Beatings go from white, which is mostly about ritual humiliation and done with rolled-up cloth, to blue and black. Those two involve a bundle of rods and are meant to be painful and injurious, respectively. And then there is the death penalty." He took another bite of mutton.

"The red beating, which is administered by cudgel with the goal of a painful death." Phaidros nodded, and Brutus gestured at the stacks of jurisprudence.

"So how would you calibrate the black and blue beatings your father has been handing out?" Favius narrowed his eyes and stared at the letters.

"Well, the sticks in the bundle for a blue beating are to have the thickness of a child's fingers, whereas a black beating involves sticks the thickness of a man's fingers. And the severity of the crime determines the tool, cadence, and placement of the beating." Brutus grinned like a cat that had caught a mouse.

"And say, which tree species do you deem appropriate for which kind of crime?" Phaidros chuckled as Favius rolled his eyes.

"I don't have a clue, to be honest. Hazel or willow, whatever is available."

"Truly, such a simple solution," began Phaidros.

"Have you not considered the mystic significance of choosing between alder and oak?" Phaidros raised two fingers to forestall any comment. This narrative has been purloined without the author's approval. Report any appearances on Amazon.

"For that matter, the import of choosing a tree grown in the correct place." All of them chuckled, and Favius helplessly gestured to the entire stack of letters concerning that subject.

"It's mostly the Traditionalist faction that seems to concern itself with that." Though I can't say I'm surprised about them having an almost occult mysticism about selecting the correct kind of rods. Just the kind of irrelevant detail where people can argue about it endlessly. Brutus interrupted his thoughts with another question.

"And what of Marcus' creative ideas for punishing your slave?" Favius let his shoulders slump.

"As I understand it, while there's a theoretical provision for creative forms of red beatings, the Reformist faction of jurists has tightened the boundaries around those things significantly. Though of course they still occur for extraordinary crimes, especially treason." He recalled the story Sirrana had told him about the punishment the young Vitaii mages, who had brainwashed one of their fellows, had received under Aelia's oversight.

And I can't say that there isn't a point to deterring people strongly from the most heinous category of crimes. Brutus sipped some wine and shook his head.

"Do you still believe that just locking people up for dozens of cycles in a small cell is morally superior to giving them a proper beating and sending them to a mine?" He raised two fingers before Favius could throw out the obvious objection.

"Not a salt or lead mine, obviously, but an ordinary copper mine, where the Mountain God will judge if they remain with him forever or if they are going to be free after their term." Phaidros' eyes narrowed in suspicion.

"That's a very strange question, Brother." The side of Brutus' mouth twitched.

"My Young Dominus is a very strange boy, as you might have noticed." Phaidros narrowed his eyes at Favius.

"You truly believe that imprisonment and boredom is a superior way of justice to making people work off their debts?" Favius let his head fall forward onto his hands and waved them off.

"I can see that there is a point to having criminals work, though...

"I still object to the treatment of slaves in salt and lead mines. After all, a judge uses his judgment and does not dispense ideal justice." He paused and considered his wine cup in hand again.

"And I understand what will happen to Tiro. Beyond any legal doubt, he earned his death. And I don't think Marcus will go after his family's graves, but his sons..." His eyes flicked again to the letter he had been reading before, and he straightened.

"Justice ought to be just, not cruel." Phaidros laughed harshly.

"I very much agree, boy. Though, had the Archon I offended understood that simple principle, I would be buried in the soil of my homeland instead of being a married man in your Republic." Favius raised an eyebrow, and Phaidros leaned back after snapping an olive out of the air.

"The city of Verdant Hills is governed by a council of seven Archons. The heir of one of whom..." The Magnicultor's voice grew low, and Favius felt the fury radiating off the man.

"... raped a cousin of mine whom I grew up alongside, thinking that just because she was from a minor Archonal line, they would not dare press charges against him." Favius glanced between the two men and swallowed hard, his guts tied.

"And you did something about that?" Phaidros chuckled, yet there was no smile on his face.

"I sought that wastrel out when he was drinking with his friends at one of the lodges of Sydian. My friends distracted his, and I used the first flimsy pretext in our argument to challenge him to a duel."

"You killed him," murmured Favius, unable not to glance toward the Penal Code. A low noble killing a high noble, even in a duel… Phaidros shook his head.

"Even in my youthful drive for justice, I was more careful than that." He shook his head.

"I used my even then considerable skill at unarmed combat to beat him to the point where he might receive advice from his ancestors without passing into oblivion."

"You're forgetting to mention that you also gelded him with repeated kicks, and that that was what the Archon objected to most strenuously." Phaidros hummed and let his hand run over his gold-and-peacock-feather-covered sash, somehow seeming as terribly regal as Marcus.

"I stand by what I did." He shook his head and refocused on Favius.

"And so the Archon sent assassins after me."

"Assassins? How old were you?" Phaidros gave a pained expression.

"Beyond my second majority, as you would count it here. So my cultivation was already considerable enough to kill the first two parties that came after me.

"Had the Archon paid them to simply deliver my head without cruelty, I don't think I would have had a chance." The athlete grinned viciously.

"But he insisted that my death ought to be torturous and offered them a bonus for getting me alive." Phaidros's fists pressed shut and opened again.

"Which gave me all the openings I needed to survive and realize that I was no longer welcome in Minuria." They sat there in silence, the heroic athlete looking somewhere into the distance.

"And your family?" murmured Favius. Phaidros just shook his head.

"Unlike in your Republic, exterminating your enemies' families is viewed much more dimly under the Archons. The man's quarrel was with me, and only questionably just in the first place." He shook his head.

"With my effective exile, it would have cost too much to push further. The other six would have taken too much meat from the man. After all, old nobles temper the cruelty that young men like to clothe in talk of justice with political pragmatism." Favius nodded in agreement. Not that I don't understand the instinct. Making someone hurt who hurt you is emotionally very satisfying, even though it often gets you to places where you shouldn't go.

Musing, he noted all too late that Phaidros was studying him intently again.

"Yet that fire does not appear to burn in you, Favius. One of your many..." He glanced over at Brutus.

"... if you permit me to say so, strange attitudes and talents." Favius studiously chewed another piece of mutton and did not look up as Phaidros continued.

"I would be very curious to hear how you developed such a peculiar sense of justice." Swallowing down the meat, Favius focused intently on picking the next morsel. This is the second or third time where he's almost asking me outright what's up with me. He's already on the list of people who will be told something, though I'm not quite sure how much. He glanced over at Brutus, whose look agreed with Favius' thoughts. But this is the kind of conversation we ought to have in the cave.

Before the conversation could push on, a servant knocked on the door and entered.

"Young Dominus, your father agreed to your request to have dinner with him. If you would follow me?" Favius smiled at the two Magnicultors and glanced at the legal documents with which he had sharpened the argument for the evening before getting up.

"Yes. Lead the way."